From Protestant Pastor to Catholic Digital Evangelist: Interview with Keith Nester

Mar 12, 2025 by

Brandon Duncan

What would make a devoted Protestant pastor leave behind 22 years of ministry, his congregation, and his career to become Catholic?

Now a dynamic content creator and evangelist, Keith shares his inspiring conversion story—one filled with deep theological discoveries, personal struggles, and a powerful encounter with the Blessed Virgin Mary.

In our conversation, Keith opens up about his early misconceptions about Catholicism, the pivotal role of authority and tradition in his faith journey, and how his ministry now reaches thousands worldwide through his Rosary Crew, Unpacking the Mass series, and his popular podcast, Catholic Feedback. He also offers invaluable advice for parishes and individuals seeking to evangelize through digital platforms.

If you're looking for encouragement, practical evangelization tips, and a reminder that God’s plans are always greater than our own, this is an episode you don’t want to miss!